Broadcast Standards Council tosses latest Sun News Network vulgarity back to CRTC

Sun News Network commentator Ezra Levant assails your blogger for his many ideological imperfections. Great picture! …of me.

The Canadian Broadcast Standards Council has asked the federal broadcast regulator, the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission, to investigate complaints about a June 13 broadcast by Sun News Network commentator Ezra Levant.

The CBSC said in a letter to this blogger that it will not itself investigate complaints about Sun News Network’s June 13 episode of Mr. Levant’s program The Source because “the comments in question are about the CBSC and identified individuals who volunteer as our Panel members.”

As a result, the CBSC said, it finds itself in a conflict of interest and is therefore not in a position to deal with complaints arising from the June 13 broadcast. Complaints about the broadcast will be forwarded to the CRTC, the federal agency that oversees the broadcasting and telecommunications industries, the CBSC letter said.

In normal cases, the CRTC refers complaints it receives about the content of television or radio broadcasts to the CSBC, which describes itself on its website as “an independent, non-governmental organization created by the Canadian Association of Broadcasters to administer standards established by its members, Canada’s private broadcasters.”

On June 13, Sun News Network and Mr. Levant complied with a ruling of the CBSC censuring them for using on the air in 2011 a Spanish profanity universally understood to mean “f**k your mother,” and for clearly identifying the individual at whom Mr. Levant directed this and other insults, by reading a required statement.

The ruling noted that Mr. Levant had made the following remark on the air as part of his Dec. 22, 2011, commentary about a report the Chiquita Brands food company had announced it would avoid using oil from Alberta’s bitumen sands: “Hey you. Yeah you, [name of Chiquita executive]. Chinga tu madre.” Referring to the commentary as “a tirade,” the ruling noted Mr. Levant also said “in a distinctly aggressive tone” that the Chiquita executive was a liar.

Under the terms of Sun News Network’s voluntary membership in the CBSC, the June 13 ruling required the right-wing U.S.-style broadcaster to read on the air a statement that it had breached the CAB’s Code of Ethics in the 2011 broadcast of Mr. Levant’s program. “The program contained a coarse insult directed at a specific named person,” said the statement Sun News Network was required to read. “This violated Clause 6 of the Code.”

But during the June 13 broadcast, in addition to reading the words of the statement required by the CBSC, Mr. Levant repeated the same offensive phrase several times, and harshly criticized the four members of the panel that issued the ruling. (He also criticized this blogger, who had filed one of 22 complaints about Sun News Network’s use of the phrase.)

At various times during the broadcast, Mr. Levant referred to the CBSC as “idiots,” “stupid,” “a group of nobodies,” “the secretive group of censors,” “a kangaroo court,” “busybodies, know-it-alls and snoops,” and “arrogant little bureaucrats.” During the broadcast, he also implied that federal Opposition Leader Thomas Mulcair belonged on a list of enemies of Canada.

Mr. Levant argued, moreover, that “even if I told Chiquita to ‘chinga tu madre’ every day, it’s not against the rules that the censors claim to be following.” Based on this argument, he called the statement Sun News Network was asked to read “a false confession” and “the lie they wanted me to tell.”

Mr. Levant closed his broadcast with the following words, which included a reference to the first names of each of the four panel members: “Hey censors! Yeah, you, Troy, Pip, Lea, Andree, the whole Broadcast Standards Council, Chiquita, ForestEthics. I’ve got a message for ya! ‘Chinga tu madre!’” (Andree Noel, the chair of the panel, is the national chair of the CBSC and a former Quebec regional commissioner of the CRTC.)

On June 20, a lawyer for Quebecor Media informed the CSBC and the 22 complainants in an email that “…the statement was broadcast during The Source on Wednesday, June 13, 2012 and again on Thursday, June 14, 2012. … The two broadcasts of the statement therefore met the requirements for airing the statement set out in the CBSC’s decision.” (Emphasis added.)

As leaders of an organization arguably created for the benefit of its member corporations, the officers of the CBSC must have been gobsmacked by Sun News Network’s response, which was not restricted to Mr. Levant’s remarks. The Sun News website referred to the CSBC as “a kangaroo court manned by Sun News competitors.”

It is easy to infer that the destruction of the CBSC must be Sun News Network’s goal, and it may well succeed with that part of its program.

However, as has been said in this space before, a government agency charged with enforcing broadcast standards is a more appropriate venue for examining questions of this nature than a toothless voluntary organization that, it can be persuasively argued, exists principally to inoculate its members against the possibility of actual regulation being enforced in the interests of Canadians, who own the airwaves from which its member companies generate handsome profits.

But it is not clear if the CRTC today has the will, the regulatory tools or the internal mechanisms to deal with complaints of this nature, a situation that would effectively leave the public’s airwaves in the hands of completely unregulated and clearly irresponsible corporations with an extremist political agenda.

So it needs to be repeated that the line that connects Prime Minister Stephen Harper and his market-fundamentalist Conservative Party of Canada to the foul-mouthed hyper-partisanship of the Sun News Network and its offensive commentators is short and direct, and that they act in the service of common goals.

This post also appears on Rabble.ca.

10 Comments on "Broadcast Standards Council tosses latest Sun News Network vulgarity back to CRTC"

  1. Skinny Dipper says:

    If and when the CRTC makes a decision about Ezra Levant’s comments, it will likely limit its decision based on the licensing conditions required on the Sun News Network.

    I didn’t hear Levant make any apology. If he had, I’m sure he would have apologized the way a little kid apologizes but doesn’t mean it.

    “So-r-r-r-r-r-r-r-y.”

    Ezra Levant makes an interesting point about four people who decided on the complaint against him and Sun News. He does note their potential conflict-of-interest. They either work or have worked for the competitors of Sun News, or they have been former political appointees outside the CBSC. I won’t suggest that the four made a bad ruling. Far from it. However, Levant and Sun News can make their case to the CRTC and any court that the CBSC members who decided on this complaint had a pre-conditioned bias against Sun News.

  2. Jerrymacgp says:

    While I think that Levant’s views are odious in the extreme, I wonder whether in fact he ought to be stifled? The rationale for regulating broadcasters is that the “airwaves” over which they distribute their signals are public property. However, does Sun News Network actually broadcast over the public airwaves? Or is it only available via cable or satellite to its subscribers, who can choose or not to pay for it or to view it? If they are not using the “public airwaves” to disseminate their programming, then they ought not to be subject to regulation.

    I’m just saying…

  3. ronmac says:

    I’m afraid Ezra Levant is a voice that will only be silenced when somebody accidently backs over him with a cement truck.

  4. sanwin says:

    Oh why don’t you just bugger off, you rabid left wing whiner.

  5. Filostrato says:

    Ezra Levant has been getting stranger and stranger over the last decade or so.

    I think he may be a few marbles short of a game of Chinese Checkers.

  6. Alex P says:

    Well, nobody in stifling or censoring anyone. Sun News Network are in conflict with a promise they made (along with other broadcasters) and it seems they’ve been asked to say sorry. But every time someone attempts to treat SNN like every other kid in the sandbox they cry fowl. Like when SNN wanted the CRTC to force cable companies to carry their channel. Faced with the fact that no channel is mandated by the CRTC they cried foul. (Correct me if I’m wrong.) A regulatory agency’s job is to always to rule in the benefit of Sun News, what else.

    All I can say is, I’ll be in the kitchen, ’cause I see you’re on the cross.

  7. Others in the media could benefit from a little injection of nonconformity in their cookie cutter reportage. Ezra Lavant has the capacity to be offensive because he is an individual and not merely a mannequin propped up in front of a camera/microphone whose mouth is being operated by some Casper Milquetoast bureaucrats hand up their arse.

    Like a longshoreman who when unloading a ships cargo carries double the weight of his fellows, Lavant’s work ethic and dedication to providing hard-hitting commentary to the Canadian citizen while all around him are just mailing it in to collect a paycheck they do not deserve tends to upset the slackers so it is understandable that the ‘Average’ and ‘Mediocre’ “journalists” might get their knickers in a twist.

    Lavant’s head sticks up considerably higher than the rest of the weeds in the wasteland of Canadian Media so of course the whirring blade of Nanny-State Censorship will be directed his way.

    This opponent of Censorship says let Lavant speak, and prompt, and goad, and push and pull and drag his inferior fellows up out of the mire of political correctness into which they have descended so that they may stand on his level and give Canadians their unfettered journalistic considered opinion on matters which affect us.

  8. badbeta says:

    You have a problem with Ezra, deal with him directly. Quit acting like a little pansy and running off to Daddy to deal with your issues. Some journalist you are.

    Maybe if you had been in a fist fight or two growing up you wouldn’t be such a eunuch now.

  9. Alex P says:

    Please to be watching Bill Maher on fourteen year old conservatives. http://youtu.be/6KrdhcPXxRA (Language warning, starts at 2:00)

    I know Ezra went to university, he can do better.

Trackbacks for this post

  1. Sun News Network apologizes … sort of … while the CRTC runs and the CBSC surrenders | Alberta Diary

Comment